Michelle Miller
In the pursuit of clean, reliable, and affordable power, North Carolina has found itself at the crossroads of energy policy. The recent blackout experienced by Duke Energy customers on Christmas Eve has sparked discussions about the state’s energy infrastructure and the role of intermittent renewables. While the debate rages on, it is essential to dissect the arguments presented by different stakeholders and examine potential solutions to fortify the grid against future disruptions.
The Advocates for Renewables
Conservatives for Clean Energy (CCE) and Governor Roy Cooper suggest that an increased share of intermittent renewables, such as wind and solar, could have averted the Christmas Eve blackouts. They refer to Duke Energy’s testimony, emphasizing that equipment failures at coal and natural gas plants were the primary culprits. However, the narrative seems incomplete.
Duke Energy’s Testimony
Duke Energy’s testimony, as highlighted by critics, fails to acknowledge the multifaceted nature of the blackout. While equipment failures did contribute, it was not the sole factor. Modeling forecast discrepancies, unmaterialized purchased power, and issues with cold weather protective measures collectively led to a significant loss of power during the early hours of Christmas Eve. The nuances in Duke’s testimony underscore the challenges faced by traditional power sources in extreme weather conditions.
The Solar Conundrum
Renewable energy, particularly solar, faced constraints due to its intermittent nature. Duke Energy’s acknowledgment that solar performed as “expected” implies that it was not available during peak demand since the peak occurred before sunrise. This raises questions about the reliability of solar energy during critical periods.
Grid-Scale Batteries as a Solution
CCE proposes grid-scale industrial batteries as a solution to enhance the reliability of renewable energy. However, concerns are raised about the affordability and reliability of such solutions. The cost of grid-scale batteries, estimated at around $700,000 per MWh, presents a significant financial hurdle. Moreover, their degradation over time poses long-term sustainability challenges.
The Nuclear Energy Alternative
Curiously absent from the discourse is the mention of nuclear energy, a clean, reliable, and cost-effective power source. Duke Energy’s testimony highlighted the reliability of nuclear units during the blackout event, producing a substantial portion of electricity. The potential of nuclear energy to stabilize the grid and minimize blackouts remains a pivotal aspect that warrants consideration.
Regional Power Markets (RTOs) – A Controversial Proposition
CCE suggests evaluating the possibility of joining a regional power market or Regional Transmission Organization (RTO) to achieve cost savings. However, the call for a closer look at RTOs comes with its own set of controversies. Critiques highlight how RTOs contribute to higher costs, grid fragility, and a lack of accountability, drawing attention to the vulnerabilities exposed during incidents like the Texas grid collapse in 2021.
The Case Against RTOs
Meredith Angwin’s book, “Shorting the Grid: The Hidden Fragility of Our Electric Grid,” serves as a cautionary tale against the pitfalls of RTOs. It delves into the intricacies of America’s electricity system, particularly the role of RTOs, emphasizing their contribution to grid fragility. The Texas grid collapse serves as a stark illustration of the potential risks associated with an overreliance on weather-dependent energy sources.
The Path Forward
As North Carolina contemplates its energy future, a comprehensive approach that prioritizes reliability, affordability, and sustainability is imperative. The merits and drawbacks of intermittent renewables, grid-scale batteries, and the often-overlooked nuclear energy should be thoroughly evaluated. Simultaneously, the potential implications of embracing or rejecting regional power markets demand a nuanced understanding.
In a landscape marked by evolving energy policies, the emphasis should be on ensuring a resilient grid that can weather diverse challenges. The lessons learned from Christmas Eve 2022 and other blackout incidents across the nation should inform a robust energy strategy that aligns with the state’s unique needs and priorities.
In the pursuit of a clean energy future, North Carolina stands at a critical juncture, where thoughtful decision-making will shape the trajectory of its power infrastructure for years to come. Balancing innovation, reliability, and economic considerations will be key to achieving a sustainable energy landscape that benefits both present and future generations.
Learn More: Video Interview on Colorado blackouts and grid reliability
